Just like the Oscars telecast, Anne Hathaway's gown this year was kind of painful to watch. Why would she wear this strapless tafetta Valentino Couture gown with rosette details when it looks like it came with a bedskirt or window treatment attached to it? And the makeup is overkill, as well. Too bad—we were expecting a lot more from this star, who almost always shuts it down on the red carpet. Good thing the show, and this dress, are done for the night.