Michael Becker / FOX
Casey Abrams
The season-10 contestant only finished sixth—and that was partly because the judges used their one save of the season five weeks beforehand—but he was a cult fave. He performed on the Idols Live tour, cut a cover of "Baby, It's Cold Outside" with fellow finalist (and rumored flame) Haley Reinhart, and ultimately signed with jazz label Concord.
News /
Due Date
Photos /
More Galleries
Biggest Celeb Dramas Ever
How to Spot the Real Thing
12 Quality Items You Absolutely Must Have
Kim Kardashian's & Kate Middleton's Pregnancy Styles
Videos /
Amanda Bynes' Shocking Tweet
Photos /
Grecian Kim