Major mascara turnoffs for girls who don't like makeup? Clumpiness and goopy formulas that transfer to lids. This lash enhancer—made by Shailene Woodley's favorite beauty brand—not only boasts a natural formula; it gives lashes a slightly-better-than-natural look (without the mess).
100% Pure Fruit Pigmented Mascara: Green Tea, $25
When applying highlighters with fingers, it's hard to strike a natural balance. This creamy bronzing highlighter is super easy to use—thanks to its domed shape—and helps keep a pearlescent-spiked glow in check.
Body Shop Honey Bronze Highlighting Dome, $16
Summer shine is a beast that even bare-faced girls wish to tame. What to do if you hate the way that powder builds up and settles into pores and creases? Try a mattifying primer to rid your skin of shine instead. This formula can be used under or over BB creams and feels featherlight to boot.
Paula's Choice Shine Stopper Instant Matte Finish, $23
Major pigment looks great—until it fades or smears. This lip shade delivers a sheer wash of color and gives the payoff of a high-impact lipstick, but without the potential blunders. Instead, it leaves a fresh, popsicle-stained effect that feels as light as a lip balm.
Urban Decay Sheer Revolution Lipstick, $22
For the girl who hates the sensation of base makeup on her face, even the lightest of foundations can feel suffocating. Thankfully, this ultralight BB cream—which is made with skin-nourishing ingredients like coconut water, kelp extract and jojoba esters—evens skin tone and reduces redness but feels like nothing is on.
Pacifica Alight Multi-Mineral BB Cream, $16
Brows are such thing right now that it's hard not to want in on the action (even if makeup isn't your bag). While darkening brows with makeup may seem scary to a low-maintenance girl, there are tools to make the process simple: The microfine point on this pen allows you to enhance brows with ultra-precise strokes, keeping the overall look natural—and doing wonders to frame your face.
Make Brow Pen, $20
The hangup with many lip and cheek stains? They're hard to control—and no less-is-more girl wants to emerge with red-dotted cheeks like Raggedy Ann. This convertible lip and cheek color is made with creamy coconut oil and deposits color evenly, leaving nothing but a natural tint.
RMS Beauty Lip 2 Cheek, $36
For the makeup averse, eyeshadows can be tricky: Light hues can add too much sparkle and darker shades make eyes look small. To enhance the eyes without looking like you've done anything at all, consider lining the lower waterline with a nude liner. This will make eyes look bigger and brighter—and looks perfect with a quick swipe of mascara.
Sigma Inner Rim Brightener, $9