Project Runway All Stars: Who Didn't Have a Prayer With Godspell?

Plus, which designer is making their Broadway debut? Find out...

It's safe to say we weren't the only ones shocked to see Rami Kashou go last week, as witnessed by the beginning of tonight's Project Runway All Stars episode.

But there was no time to grieve the loss of a great designer, because the remaining seven had to come up with something spectacular for award-winning composer Stephen Schwartz's Broadway musical Godspell.

The winner would get their design featured in the show and their bio listed in the Playbill!

Basically, the designers had to come up with an outfit—requiring separates since the performer will be putting on this look while onstage—for a "rich woman" character, played by Uzo Aduba.

Think feathers, faux fur, exotic prints and crazy accessories.

The judges, including Tony-winning Broadway star Sutton Foster in the guest spot, chose Mondo Guerra as the winner of this challenge for his eccentric jacket paired with a long halter dress layered with different patterned fabrics. It might sound weird, but it really was gorgeous.

Unfortunately, Mila Hermanovski and Kara Janx were on the bottom.  

Although she stepped out of her comfort zone with tonight's look, Kara was out due to a lack of construction (the slit on the skirt skewed a little) and one giant silver bow.