Movie Reviews

Hot-buttered opinion on the latest flicks

Hello, you either have JavaScript turned off or an old version of Adobe's Flash Player. Get the latest Flash player.

The Golden Compass

The Golden Compass Laurie Sparham/Newline.wireimage.com
A-

Review in a Hurry:  A young girl is the only hope of a parallel world filled with talking animals, sky cowboys, polar bear death matches and a totalitarian regime that would bring tears of joy to Dick Cheney's eyes. Based on the His Dark Materials trilogy by Philip Pullman, this adaptation is a gorgeous, overstuffed contender for the box-office crown of Harry Potter.

The Bigger Picture:  Lyra (Dakota Blue Richards) is an orphan in a world parallel to ours, where people's souls live outside them in the shape of talking animals called daemons. Alchemy is science here, and the bad guys, called the Magisterium, run almost everything. Think 1984 set in Narnia.

But things aren't too shabby for Lyra. She lives at a college that's the last bastion of freethinking, and her uncle is James Bond...sorry, Lord Asriel, an adventurer and scholar played by Daniel Craig. Asriel thinks he's found a way into other parallel worlds, and this discovery kicks off a battle against the Magisterium with Lyra at its center.

If you've read Pullman's books, you know all this—in fact, you're probably in line for the movie already. For everyone else, this is where Lyra is forced to confront her destiny. Standing in her way is Nicole Kidman, whose porcelain exterior hides a heart as cold as Darth Vader's.

Lyra's journey is a pretty standard trip down the hero path: orphan, check; magic object, check; war between good and evil, check. But it's a quest through a fully realized world, filled with an attention to detail that's far too rare in most films. From the airships above the Byzantine cities to the expressions on the faces of the animals, the magic seems almost real enough to touch.

The 180—a Second Opinion:  The filmmakers give you a brief voice-over to explain the setup, and from there, any questions are left to the stultifying dialogue. It's a crime to have Sir Ian McKellen's rich voice used to lay down backstory like pipe. Kids and fantasy geeks won't mind these climbs up the steep side of exposition hill, but if you can't admire the scenery during the slow parts and the detours around logic, you'll probably wish you'd skipped this ride.

0 Comments

Now loading...

Add Your Comment!

Guests

E! Online members

Register | Forgot password?

Play nice and have fun. And please, no HTML tags or special characters including [&*#()!@$].
You've got 1000 characters left.

Post Comment