The Best and Worst New Shows of 2016...According to You

This time, you got to be the judge

By Lauren Piester Nov 01, 2016 7:15 PMTags

It is time, ladies and gentlemen, to lay down the final judgment on this season's new fall shows. 

You watched, you voted, and now the results are in, meaning we can finally decide which shows are a success and which shows have not won a season pass on your DVR. 

Did you pretty much agree with our original ranking, or did you have totally different opinions—meaning we're now in a fight? There's only one way to find out, and that's to click through the gallery below, featuring your ranking of all the new fall shows from worst to best. 

photos
2016's Best and Worst New Fall Shows—According to You!

While we basically agreed on some of the best shows (This Is Us, hello), there were a few surprises! 

Timeless jumped from our #11 to your #3, and you guys definitely had much fuzzier feelings towards Man with a Plan than we did. You also really hated a couple of shows that we were a little more fond of, but that's fine. This is America, and different opinions are allowed! 

Take a look at the gallery above, then head to the comments with your thoughts!