Olivia Wilde's Fiancé Jason Sudeikis Makes Her "Admit" to Same-Sex Past

Love the Coopers actress tells Andy Cohen she appreciates "all people"

By Samantha Schnurr Oct 16, 2015 5:16 PMTags

Much like her last name, Olivia Wilde has had one secret wild past! Thanks to her husband Jason Sudeikis,now we know all about it. 

During a round of Andy Cohen's "Plead The Fifth" on Watch What Happens Live Thursday night, the 31-year-old mother refused to answer the scandalous first question posed to her by her partner of two years when he asked, "Where's the wildest place you've done the deed?"

Wilde wisely plead the fifth, thinking she had just escaped untouched.

However, Sudekis clearly could anticipate his fiancé's thinking, so he followed up with an even juicer question.

"Have you ever dipped into the lady pond in real life?" he asked inquisitively. 

"My man! What's going on?" the BoJack Horseman actress reacted to the deeply-personal inquisition, finally succumbing with a weak subtle response. "I appreciate all people."

Cohen would not be fooled. "I will accept that as a yes," he said grinning. 

While she may stay mum when it come's to her past canoodling, she did reveal to Cohen which on-screen girl kiss she enjoyed the most. While her hook-up with Ashley Greene in Butter captivated audiences and the media, Wilde has her mind on one other famous smooch—with Mischa Barton

"When we were doing The O.C., I really thought we were doing the responsible thing by showing two young sweet girls in a real relationship not just having a sorority girls splash happy make-out."

But, apparently it was all in the name of a good cause.  

"I joked about it inspiring a young generation of young lesbians, but I do think that it represented an alternative lifestyle for young women that I don't think that had been fairly represented enough in young soapy drama."

Wilde finished the thought with one final note. 

"Mischa, two thumbs up."  

Well, that settles that.

Watch: Having a Baby Improved Olivia Wilde's Acting Chops!