Tina Fey Planned Daughter Alice's Epic Surprise Party...With Alec Baldwin Masks? Watch Now!

This Is Where I Leave You star tells Seth Meyers she's not sure if she "subconsciously"wants kids' costumes to look like 30 Rock pal

By Rebecca Macatee Sep 18, 2014 1:52 PMTags

30 Rock might be over, but Tina Fey just can't get away from Alec Baldwin!

On Wednesday's Late Night With Seth Meyers, the This Is Where I Leave You star talked about daughter Alice's surprise birthday party and how Jack Donaghy somehow made an appearance.

"We had this whole thing of dress up and have a disguise," said Tina, who admitted it's "so easy" to surprise a 9-year-old. So Mama Fey "got all these wigs and things and like a generic mask and whatever."

"But then I got the pictures back," she said, "and what had appeared to be a generic—I thought just like a generic man mask—in all the pictures [it] looks exactly like Alec Baldwin!"

Seth agreed, calling the resemblance "eerie." Tina couldn't help but wonder, "Did I subconsciously buy an Alec Baldwin mask?"

"I went online to see if you can buy an Alec Baldwin mask," she said. "It's not. Apparently, I'm told that it's actually meant to be a Jim Parsons [from the] Big Bang Theory mask."

"It's not, though," said Seth. "That's an Alec Baldwin mask!"

Tina agreed wholeheartedly. "Look at that beautiful mouth." she pointed to a picture of the mask. "That's like kissable Alec Baldwin mouth!"

Seth saw the humor, too, telling Tina, "Nothing's funnier to me than a little girl who's like, "I want to be Alec Baldwin!'"

(E! and NBC are both part of the NBCUniversal family.)