But now in May, it seems that the figure skater turned broadcaster and his lawyer love are definitely headed for divorce again following two alleged altercations between them this weekend.
Victor's legal crisis manager Wendy Feldman tells E! News "police were called" to the scene Friday night, "but nothing happened." On Saturday, though, she claims "there was another altercation, and that one was physical."
Wendy says the pair, who wed Dec. 31, 2011, in a civil ceremony in New York, "gave it a shot. They went to marriage counseling and they tried..." She also believes that Johnny "had a different agenda" than her client, saying, the fashionable athlete "was on a fact-finding mission to gather evidence for the divorce rather than pursuing an actual reconciliation."
So what does this mean for the couple moving forward? According to Victor's legal crisis counselor, the "divorce was never pulled, so the terms still stand."
"Victor is currently at the apartment," she says. "Johnny pays the rent and expenses, and it's where Victor remains."
A rep for Johnny has not yet returned E! News' request for comment.
—Additional reporting by Marcus Mulick