Well, we might just be in luck! Sources tell E! News the Lovelace star and the iSteve actor are dating, but it's still "recent." According to Us Weekly, who was first to report the news, the stars are "hanging out more, going on date-like activities," and just "seeing where it goes."
On July 30, 2013, at the Lovelace premiere in New York, Justin, 35, came out to support his leading lady. "They weren't making out or anything like that," a source told the mag, "but they were just inseparable during the event. He hung out when she talked with others.
Since then, the pair have been finding time to spend together, despite their busy schedules. Case in point? Thursday night, an eyewitness spotted Amanda and Justin having dinner at Cecconi's, an Italian restaurant in West Hollywood.
"They seemed like they were on a third or fourth date, smiley but still seemed to be getting to know each other," remarked one astute observer. The pair talked the "entire time" at dinner, both enjoying glasses of white wine throughout their meal.
Reps for Justin and Amanda did not respond to E! News' request for comment.
—Additional reporting by Ruth O'Neill and Melanie Bromley