Spoiler alert! Our roundup of the night's most memorable TV moments will brief you on the biggest and best happenings from Tuesday's shows—some of which you might not have seen yet.
So, look away if you don't want to know! And get ready to geek out along with us!
Pretty Little Liars: While we've yet to learn if Toby (Keegan Allen) really was the dead person Spencer (Troian Bellisario) found in the woods, we can officially eliminate one person fans have been guessing it could've been: Detective Wilden, who returned alive and well and ready to stir up more trouble for Hanna (Ashley Benson).
And it seems Spencer is definitely on a one-way trip to Crazytown as she finds herself in the Radley Sanitarium, telling a group of strangers, "Don't know who I am anymore. You can't trust me." The catch? She's picturing her group of besties. Yikes!
Justified: The FX hit finally revealed Drew Thompson to be...Shelby (Jim Beaver)! Were you surprised? Sound off in the comments!
White Collar: In the USA hit's season finale, Peter (Tim DeKay) finds himself in jail after Neal's (Matt Bomer) father James (Treat Williams) kills Senator Pratt with Peter's gun. When Neal begs his father to turn himself in and help Peter, James says, "Let me give you some advice: In this life, somebody always takes a fall. Don't let it be you." Way harsh, dude!
Also during the hour, Neal delivered one epic marriage proposal to Sara (Hilarie Burton), telling her, "The first time we kissed, I realized I don't want anything…except you. And now I'm asking if you'll go on one more adventure with me." Alas, it was all a ruse concocted by the duo to secure evidence, though Neal does admit he meant what he said. Of their romance, Sara wistfully says, "Another time, another place." Best. Fake. Proposal. Ever. Right?!
Line of the Night: "Even though I don't like you right now, I don't hate you." There's still hope yet, Zoe (Rachel Bilson) and Wade (Wilson Bethel) fans after Hart of Dixie's cheating shocker last week. Side note: Even junk-food-covered, messy-breakup-version of Zoe is adorable. That Bilson lady is a magician or wizard or something.
This Just In: Hot on the heels of 90210's recent cancelation, star Matt Lanter has already booked his next gig. Lanter is set to star opposite Aimee Teegarden in the pilot Oxygen for the CW. He'll take on the role of Roman, an alien boy who is one of nine of his kind integrated into a normal high school. Think modern Roswell, basically, and he is Jason Behr. THR first reported the news of Lanter's casting.
This Also Just In: Ben McKenzie has been cast in a CBS pilot, The Advocates, playing an ex-con who teams up with a lawyer to help crime victims. This doesn't necessarily mean Southland is over, since the former Mr. Ryan Atwood just tweeted: "To clarify: I am doing 'Advocates' in second position to #SouthLAnd If picked up for a sixth season, I am doing that. #SouthLAnd forever." Preach!