"She didn't want to choose between favorites," the narrator says just as Perry, on a motorcycle, and Priestley, holding a stuffed bear (most character-appropriate props ever?), pop up to issue Garth an ultimatum. Sound familiar?
"I choose jeans...all of them!" Can you handle all the nostalgic goodness?!
Carteris also gets herself a piece of that Priestley pie (sort of), when she whispers, "And I love you," to the ever-clueless guy. And, of course, what would a BH90210 reunion be without a special lesson courtesy of Brandon Walsh (Priestley)?