Kevin Mazur/WireImage; Kevork Djansezian/Getty Images
But Jen's recent red carpet outing has us pitting the two actresses against each other all over again! And how could we not after seeing these dueling sheer black gowns?
Jolie wore her strapless Elie Saab frock to the 2009 Oscars, adding a pop of color with her jade green Lorraine Schwartz earrings. Aniston's look-alike style came courtesy of Dolce & Gabbana at the Just Go With It premiere in NYC.
So whose side are you gonna pick in this never-ending style showdown? Brad's former missus, with her twisted bustline and dropped waist, or his current squeeze, with her sweetheart neckline and knotted waist? Weigh in below!