• Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Jennifer Lopez, Steven Tyler, Randy Jackson, American Idol

Michael Becker / FOX

Part of the reason we love J.Lo is for her over-the-top style but Wednesday night on American Idol was about the amateur talent—not the diva behind the judges' table.

So it made total sense that she toned down her look to be Idol's encouragement coach. (Paula who?) The hair was soft and wavy, the makeup glowy but not distracting. The kind of everywoman face we might have a shot at recreating.

From the blended brown and gold shimmer shadow on her eyes and peachy blush on the apples of her cheeks to the sheer pink gloss on her lips, it was pretty perfection.

Now she just needs to work on saying, "No!"