Who says you can't have your cake and eat it too?
Although she was flip flopping between both boys recently, they hit the town together last night.
A source tells E! the three hit up Drai's at the W Hotel in Hollywood Wednesday night where they shared a VIP table and friendly conversation.
"They were all hanging out together and left together in the same car," says our source.
And the night didn't end there...
"They went to Mel's diner after for a latenight snack," says our source. "Brody and Deryck were getting along well. It looks like they've become friends."
So who did Lavigne choose at the end of the night?
"Deryck left before Avril and Brody," says our source. "They went home together."
See more stars on the scene in Party Pics: Hollywood!