Who Should Replace Simon Cowell?

Idol judge is mum on his replacement, but we've got a few theories. Who's your favorite?

First Paula Abdul, now Simon Cowell. What the heck is going on over there at American Idol?

Still, replacing either of them doesn't seem like the worst gig in the world. (Hey, it worked for Ellen.) So who else should be polishing off their resume and putting on their best interview suit?

Poll

Simon's Replacement Poll

Who should join Ellen, Kara and Randy at the judges' table?

Conan O'Brien seems to be free

Conan O'Brien seems to be free

20.2%

Let's get Paula back!

Let's get Paula back!

18.1%

Susan Boyle. Duh.

Susan Boyle. Duh.

4.6%

Diddy knows judging

Diddy knows judging

23.7%

Piers Morgan. Like Simon never left

Piers Morgan. Like Simon never left

33.5%

Vote Now