Close
BRAND NEW ON E!
category header Watch with Kristin

News/ 

SYTYCD: Who Is the Best Dancer in the History of the Show?

Danny Tidwell, Blake McGrath, Joshua Allen Joe Viles/ FOX; Jason Merritt/FilmMagic for Variety Magazine; Joe Viles/ FOX

At last night's So You Think You Can Dance competition taping in Hollywood, executive producer and judge Nigel Lythgoe told the crowd that season-three star Travis Wall (who was sitting in the audience) and many other standouts from seasons past would be doing guest performances on the 100th episode of the show, airing Thursday, July 23. And that got us thinking...

If all the dancers from SYTYCD seasons one through four were compared, who would stand out as the best? Forget "America's favorite dancer" for a second. In terms of raw talent, training, technique and sheer star power, which dancer is the very best of all?

We've created a list of some of our all-time favorite, supertalented SYTYCDers, primarily using the we-remember-your-name fame filter to decide who to include, and we want you to weigh in. Write-in votes are very much accepted since we couldn't include everyone in the poll.

So who will it be and why? Vote in the poll below, write in your vote if we missed your fave and then use all the dance expertise we know you have to explain in the comments why you think William Wingfield is better than Allison Holker! (For that matter, we'll take your fantasy pairings as well. Can you imagine William and Allison together on a Mia Michaels piece?)

RELATED VIDEOS:

FROM AROUND THE WEB
MORE ON EONLINE