• Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Lindsay Lohan, New York Magazine, Scarlett Johansson, Dolce and Gabbana Ad

Bert Stern for New York Magazine; Dolce & Gabbana

With the scarlet lips and curly blond 'do, there's no question Dolce & Gabbana wanted the face of its new makeup line to channel Marilyn Monroe.

So who better to hire than Scarlett Johansson? There's no question she exudes Old Hollywood glamour.

But what about Lindsay Lohan, who re-created the icon's "Last Sitting" for New York Magazine last year?

Who do you think makes the better Marilyn (and, yes, lifestyle antics count)?