Juliet Lewis, Scarlett Johansson, Christina Aguilera

Andrew H. Walker/Getty Images; Jason Merritt/Getty Images; Carlos Alvarez/Getty Images

Third time's a charm or just played out?

Dolce & Gabbana's lace cocktail dress has made multiple appearances on the red carpet this year: The former Mrs. Ryan Reynolds wore her belted green version with black pumps back in June for the MTV Movie Awards. Juliette Lewis followed up in October at a screening of Conviction, modeling the least adorned of the dresses in red with strappy black sandals.

Christina Aguilera put the most effort into her accessories at a Burlesque photo call in Spain last week, pairing the dress with a black patent belt, matching tights, heels and a cardigan. Does the busy look pay off, or are you a fan of ScarJo and Juliette's simpler styling?

Weigh in below and get more fashion face-offs Fridays at 10:30 p.m. on E!'s Fashion Police show!

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share