• Share
  • Tweet
  • Share
Blake Lively, Madonna, Rihanna

INFPhoto; Getty Images; Wireimage.com

It's the boot battle, part deux!

Madonna and Blake Lively both rocked Stella McCartney's sky-high thigh-highs recently. But guess who wore them first? Trendsetter Rihanna, natch, who got her sexy gams in these edgy boots back in fall 2009.

We can't have a proper face-off without including the fierce fashionista, too. So vote below and then get the final results Friday at 10:30 p.m. on E!'s Fashion Police show!