Taylor Momsen, Alice Cooper

Kevin Mazur/Wireimage; VEUIGE/Dalle/startraksphoto.com

Just in time for Halloween, it's a jack-'o-lantern-inspired showdown for the creepiest peepers possible.

See, Taylor Momsen thinks she's cornered the market on bad makeup, but she's got some company in that glam-goth costume category...

Heavy metal rocker Alice Cooper has been wearing black eyes onstage since the '70s.

Seems like Little J's got a way to go before the 17-year-old actress-model turned Pretty Reckless singer owns the raccoon eye-look. (Of course, stunts like this could speed things up.)

But that's just us. Whose eyeliner overdose are you digging: the "No More Mr. Nice Guy" singer or Gossip Girl's youngest (and most twisted) hipster?

Vote below and then get the final results Friday at 10:30 p.m. on E!'s Fashion Police show!

Fashion Police Show Oct. 26 Poll
Whose creepy eye makeup wins this Halloween match-up?

This poll is closed

  • Share
  • Tweet
  • Share