Tuesdays at 9 on NBC
WHAT IT IS: Based on Happy Endings' creator David Caspe's real-life courtship with his now-wife Happy Endings' star Casey Wilson, Happy Endings' Casey Wilson and Veronica Mars' Ken Marino play a couple navigating life as a newly-engaged pair. (And just one more time: Happy Endings!)
YOUR RANKING: #5 (80% loved it; 20% loved it)
Chances of Survival: After an impressive debut, NBC ordered five more episodes of the sitcom, bringing its total season one count to 18. Year of Casey, suck it!